convez.ai
SkillBusca & PesquisaAvançado
dipakkrishnan

Deep Review

dipakkrishnan/deep-review-skill

Revisão crítica profunda de papers e artefatos técnicos com calibração e memória

Ver no GitHub
InicialPluginScore · de 0 a 100

Skill para revisão rigorosa e crítica adversarial de artigos e artefatos técnicos. Realiza entrevista de calibração, decompõe a revisão em passes especializadas, valida afirmações contra fontes e computações, e retorna feedback estruturado por severidade. Ideal para pré-submissão de papers, testes de provas e auditorias metodológicas.

Instalação

$npx convez-ai dipakkrishnan/deep-review-skill

1 comando no terminal: detecta o formato do repositório (marketplace ou plugin avulso) e instala via Claude Code. Requer Node 18+ e o Claude Code instalado.

Métricas

Estrelas
0
Forks
0
Acompanhando
0
Saúde
42%
Último commit
há 3 meses
Versão
v0.1.1
Issues abertas
0
Contribuidores
3

Casos de uso

  • Revisão de artigos antes de submissão
  • Verificação de correção de teoremas e provas matemáticas
  • Auditoria de métodos e experimentos empíricos
  • Análise de posicionamento em literatura científica
  • Crítica de rascunhos técnicos e gerados por IA

Veredito

Deep Review é uma ferramenta niche mas poderosa para pesquisadores e revisores que precisam de critique automática rigorosa. Está em estágio experimental com distribuição pessoal do autor, recomendado para quem tem workflows críticos de revisão técnica.

README

A tradução para o português deste README ainda está na fila.

Deep Review

Deep Review is an experimental skill for rigorous review of papers and technical artifacts.

It asks a short calibration interview, reads the artifact carefully, decomposes the review into specialist passes, checks claims against sources and computations where possible, self-critiques its own findings, and returns a severity-ranked review.

The goal is simple: find the errors a generic chat-with-file pass is likely to miss.

Deep Review can also maintain optional local review memory in .deep-review/, so future reviews can pick up the user's preferred standards, recurring concerns, and review taste. It only writes memory after explicit user approval.

What It Is Good For

  • pre-submission paper review
  • theorem or proof stress tests
  • empirical / methods audits
  • literature positioning checks
  • technical memo review
  • AI-generated draft review

Status

This is early. I am distributing it personally for now while I learn where it is most useful.

If you want to try it on a real paper or artifact, open an issue or reach out.

Install

Claude Code

Add the direct Deep Review marketplace:

/plugin marketplace add dipakkrishnan/deep-review-skill
/plugin install deep-review@deep-review-marketplace
/reload-plugins

This is the fastest install path while the approved community marketplace listing propagates.

Or copy the skill folder into a project directly:

mkdir -p .claude/skills
cp -R /path/to/deep-review-skill/skills/deep-review .claude/skills/deep-review

Then ask Claude Code:

Use $deep-review to review this paper for theorem correctness and literature positioning.

Claude.ai

Download deep-review.zip (always points at the latest release), then in Claude.ai go to Customize → Skills → + → Upload a skill and drop the zip in.

To build the zip yourself from a checkout:

scripts/package-skill.sh
# produces dist/deep-review.zip

Codex

Codex does not yet expose a marketplace-style installer for third-party plugins. Copy the skill into a Codex skills directory and restart Codex:

cp -R skills/deep-review "$CODEX_HOME/skills/deep-review"

Example Prompts

Use $deep-review to review this PDF as a skeptical economics referee. Focus on model correctness, calibration, and missing literature.
Use $deep-review to stress-test the proof of Theorem 2 and identify assumptions that do not hold.
Use $deep-review to review this technical memo. Skip copy edits and focus on unsupported claims.

What To Expect

Deep Review will usually ask a few calibration questions first:

  • What is your relationship to the artifact?
  • What kind of criticism is most useful?
  • Which parts worry you most?
  • What should it avoid spending time on?

Then it produces a markdown review with:

  • overall assessment
  • critical issues
  • significant concerns
  • minor issues
  • questions for the authors

Optionally, Deep Review can save local memory for future runs:

  • standing review preferences
  • target venues or standards
  • recurring issue patterns
  • lightweight history of reviewed artifacts

Requirements

The skill itself is instructions and references.

The helper scripts require Python. PDF extraction uses PyMuPDF:

pip install pymupdf

Privacy

Deep Review does not collect telemetry or send data to any third-party service controlled by this plugin. See PRIVACY.md.

Notes

Deep Review is not a replacement for expert human judgment. It is a way to make review cheaper, sharper, and more adversarial before you ask humans to spend scarce attention on the artifact.

Ver o original no GitHub

Bom para

Relacionados